Although the film, Diarios de Motocicleta, basically started out as a fun filled, cross country trek for 2 friends, Ernesto and Alberto, I think there were many experiences that transformed Ernesto's personality and mindset influencing him to become the leader and revolutionary that he eventually became. Ernesto's philosophy about life changed over the course of the adventure.
The first influence was when Ernesto finds himself torn between his girlfriend, Ferraya, and his commitment to serving in the leper colony, which is an end destination in the trip. He must fore go his personal wants for the commitment to volunteer in the leper community. You see Ernesto as one committed to his promise or obligation.
In early scenes of this film, Ernesto comes across as a no nonsense, straight shooter, as with the man with the neck tumor. He is almost too blunt, not tempering his delivery of the diagnosis of a tumor, but with time and experience, he develops a more sensitive side to be able to converse and empathize with those that are ill.
His compassion is evident with the old woman in Chile as he knows there is nothing he can really do to save her but offers her comfort. He develops a charisma in his interactions with the elderly and infirmed.
You can see he develops a comfort level in interacting with people he meets along the journey.He becomes a more social being as he interacts with people he meets in the towns they travel through.
As the journey progresses, you see Ernesto begin to internalize the needs of the oppressed as he meets up with the communist couple whose land has been overtaken by a big property owner. He is overwhelmed by the number of men at the mine looking for work that have lost their land due to similar over takings. He meets farmers whose property is usurped once the land is productive, and farmers uniting to care for one anothers families out of a common need. All of these situations awaken a need in Ernesto to advocate for those being victimized and oppressed.
Ernesto views the Inca ruins at Machu Pichu, realizing the Spanish force utilized to wipe out this civilization, writing in his diary "Bloodless revolution-never". This indicates he knows any revolutionary change to unite all classes will involve bloodshed.
At the leper colony, Ernesto refused to wear gloves, believing there was little risk in transmission of the disease by contact, leprosy being a disease where victims are ostracized and secluded. The river separates the sick and the healthy but also symbolizes the divide between the powerful "haves" and the weaker "have nots". I think the pivotal point of the film is when he swims across the river to get to the leper colony, symbolizing that he is one with the oppressed and setting the course for his future.
Ernesto indicates "so much injustice" that he has viewed and experienced through his trip. His speech at the birthday party indicates his philosophy of no division of the people that will be his mantra for the future. All of these experiences molded his personality and influenced the leader he became.
From our class reading, though, it seems that Guevara developed such extremist values as he became more of a revolutionary. I think his goals initially were well founded but it seems he became quite a violent extremist as he became more of a revolutionary, lending truth to his proclamation of "Bloodless revolution-never".
Wednesday, April 21, 2010
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
I, too, enjoyed this movie. As a nurse, I thought that it was a wonderful story, especially about the leper colony. When Ernesto did not wear gloves to take care of the patients, I thought of the selflessness that that took to not worry about what the patients had, that it was far more important to take care of the patients.
ReplyDeleteThe idea of a bloodless revolution is a wonderful one, it is not what usually happens. I believe that Che Guevara stayed true to his values. I realize that many do not agree with what he did, especially socialism or communism. Those ideas are frightening to us as a society, because we have seen what has happened in the past. But,knowing that the CIA was instrumental in having him murdered because he was inspiring ideas that were not what the mainstream of American society wanted is also a frightening idea. Guevara's goals were lofty, but they were important. That life is precious even if it is damaged, that the poor are as important as the rich, and that everyone has value.
Cammy Reagan
ReplyDeleteI agree with your comments. I think that Ernesto did see the river as a separation of the haves and the have nots, not just a separation of sick and healthy. I think the Incan ruins also helped him put things into perspective. He was very "bothered" by the oppression that kept occuring. Those people that had their whole lives taken away because somone bigger than they were "wanted it". I think he became a very selfless leader who wanted to stop the injustices that kept happening to those who had no way of defending their positions. Right on the mark!!!
Dianne,
ReplyDeleteI see that you noticed quite a few of the same similarities in Ernesto. Being a striaght shooter and not trying to deceive was creditworthy. Also his showing compassion to the old woman shows how he feels about his fellow man.
When he swims across the river to be with the lepers I think you were right about him "feeling" for the oppressed. Why are they not included in the celebration of my birthday? Was how Ernesto saw it - he was so selfless and was worried more about other people than himself.
What do you think he is referring to when he says "too much injustice"? What is exactly his thought pattern with that quote?
ReplyDeleteI think Ernesto is expressing how overwhelmed he is by what he has experienced. He has meet so many in his travels that have had their homes and livelihood taken from them by those more powerful. These people are barely getting by with the clothes on their backs, trying to provide for themselves and their families. As he writes this he is indicating his identification with the oppressed, an indication of things to come.
ReplyDeleteThank you for following up?
ReplyDeleteI meant !
ReplyDelete